AI returns depend on governance
Chapter 1 of Evolve sets out three tiers. Organisations move up by changing how they govern their work, not by buying more AI.
Tier 1: Personal tool
People use AI one step at a time and stay in control of every step. The gains stay with the person using it. About 60% of organisations are here.
Tier 2: Team accelerator
AI speeds up existing workflows inside controls added to the old operating model. Returns rise, then stop at that process’s ceiling. About 35%.
Tier 3: Enterprise capability
Governance and the operating model are designed together and revised every cycle. Returns grow every cycle. About 5%.
Adapted from Boston Consulting Group (2025b).
Two things decide your tier
Six AI governance questions decide whether you reach Tier 2. The four commitments from Chapter 15 decide whether Tier 3 is open:
1One point of accountability
One person holds ongoing authority over what a product team works on and what gets released.
2Persistent teams, outcome funding
The team that commits to an outcome stays to bear the consequences, and its funding is tied to that outcome.
3Consumption-speed finance
Finance reports spending against the evidence the portfolio review needs, at the pace the money is spent.
4From order-taker to order-maker
The technology function solves the business’s problems instead of collecting its requirements.
Answer from how the governance works today, whatever the documentation says.
Run it with your leadership team
- Each executive answers the paper worksheet alone before you meet.
- In the room, spend the time on the questions where the answers differ.
- Enter the agreed answers online to see the team’s tier and what it takes to reach the next one.
Repeat it after a quarter of Sprint Reviews to see whether the tier has moved.
The assessment is the Governance Diagnostic, Appendix A of Evolve: The Operating Model AI Demands by Matthew Hodgson. Read Chapter 1 free.

